// OPEN INTELLIGENCE — PUBLIC ARCHIVECASE FILE · THE RECORD
FRFRFR
← THE ARCHIVE
◆ CASE FILEThe facts, corroborated

The Nagora Disc

At about noon on 23 May 1971, near St. Lorenzen in Styria, the Munich musician Rudi Nagora heard a whistling hum and saw a silver disc zig-zag in front of the clouds. He took twelve photographs of it while his wife Hildegard looked on. Sceptics have argued the object was a thrown hubcap and investigators who examined the negatives dispute that, so this is the record of a set of photographs, not a verdict on what they show.

◆ THE SHORT VERSION

  • The Nagora Disc is a reported UAP case near St. Lorenzen, Styria, Austria, 23 May 1971.
  • Munich musician Rudi Nagora said a silver disc he saw near St. Lorenzen in Austria on 23 May 1971 stopped dead in the air, turned slowly while hovering and then appeared behind him.
  • Nagora took twelve photographs of the disc on an Agfa box camera over about ten minutes, with his wife Hildegard present.
  • Proponents say Nagora's photographs were analysed in Germany and America and showed no sign of trick photography.
  • Sceptics Klaus Webner and Rudolf Henke of GWUP argued the Nagora disc was a thrown hubcap, a reading disputed by investigators who examined the negatives.
  • For this case Fractured Realities holds 2 distinct sources and 2 distinct claimants on its resolved list.
  • The archive grades it L3 · MULTI-SOURCE — multiple independent sources attest to it.

Counts are resolved totals of what sources say, computed 2026-10-03; the reported details above are claims in the record, not findings. A record of reports, not a verdict on what happened.

EVENT DATE
23 May 1971
LOCATION
near St. Lorenzen, Styria, Austria · Austria
COORDS
47.47°N 15.37°E
INDEPENDENCE
L3 · MULTI-SOURCE
SOURCES
2 distinct
CLAIMANTS
2
STATUS
Multi-source testimony
NUMBERS COMPUTED 2026-10-03 · RESOLVED COUNTS, NOT A VERDICT
VIEW ON ATLAS →

The disc stopped dead in the air and turned slowly where it hung. Then it was suddenly behind him. Rudi Nagora was a musician from Munich on holiday with his wife when he heard a whistling and humming tone and looked up. A round silver object was moving in zig-zags in front of the clouds. He photographed it twelve times on an Agfa box camera over about ten minutes before it flew off.

What is on the record

The archive's two claimants are Nagora and his wife. The archive's tellings do not name her. The published record gives her as Hildegard Nagora. One telling places the holiday on the Austria–Germany border. The published record puts it near St. Lorenzen in Styria, though the sources do not settle which St. Lorenzen is meant, and the pin on this page is approximate.

The archive's tellings say the pictures were analysed independently in Germany and America and showed no sign of trick photography. That is the proponents' view and it is disputed. Klaus Webner in 1982 and Rudolf Henke of the sceptics' society GWUP in 1996 argued that the object was a thrown hubcap or wheel cover. Investigators who examined the negatives and interviewed the couple reject that reading. No official investigation is on record.

The photographs are the case, and they have been widely reproduced. The archive holds neither the negatives nor any of the analyses on either side. It holds two tellings that repeat the favourable verdict without the sceptical one.

Why it sits where it does

The case grades L3 on two claimants who are a married couple on holiday together, and both tellings come from one channel. Its weight lies in the photographs, with a named photographer and a published argument about what he caught on film. What the twelve frames show is not resolved here.

◆ CORROBORATION
✓2 independent video sources across 1 channel
✓2 resolved claimants
◆ SOURCES

Everything this file draws on, in the open — reports, not reality. Check us.

Watch — the tellings

Each plays the source video — right here, cued to the exact moment this case is covered.

PHOTOGRAPHDISC CRAFT1971AUSTRIA

CASE FILES STATE THE RECORD AS OUR ARCHIVE HOLDS IT — FACTS, NOT OPINION. REPORTS, NOT REALITY.

◆ CONTINUE READING
The Nagora Disc — Case File · Fractured Realities