// OPEN INTELLIGENCE — PUBLIC ARCHIVEPHOTOGRAPHIC RECORD · PLATES GRADED AT SOURCE
FRFRFR
DISPUTEDMESSAGES & CODES

The Arecibo Reply

2001 · Beside Chilbolton Observatory · Hampshire · England

◈ DIAGRAM: JOHANNES RÖSSEL · CC BY-SA 3.0 · AERIAL FILM BY BRETT PARROTT VIA YOUTUBE

WHAT IT IS

A grid of 'pixels' copying the 1974 Arecibo radio message, rewritten: silicon added, the DNA changed, a big-headed figure in place of the human, a new transmitter. It appeared beside a radio telescope.

THE ALIEN READING

Read by proponents as an answer to the message humanity beamed at the M13 star cluster in 1974, delivered next to a radio telescope. With Crabwood it is the formation most cited on r/UFOs and r/HighStrangeness as a message.

WHAT THE RECORD SAYS

The SETI Institute called an other-than-earthly origin 'highly improbable'. The 1974 signal has covered about a thousandth of the distance to M13, the 'reply' adds nothing the original did not contain, and its transmitter copies a formation made in the same field in 1999 (The Skeptic, 2023). No maker has claimed it.

WHERE IT STANDS

Disputed. No maker has claimed it. Sceptics say people made it; proponents point to what they say people could not do.

STATUS IS OUR CURRENT ASSESSMENT, NOT A VERDICT · REVIEWED 5 OCT 2026

THE RECORD

DATE
2001
PLACE
Beside Chilbolton Observatory · Hampshire · England
MADE BY
Unclaimed
TYPE
Messages & codes
TECHNICAL
Wheat · a 23 × 73 grid in the Arecibo format · sources date it 16–20 August 2001

MORE FROM VOL. III · CROP CIRCLES

The Arecibo Reply, 2001 · Fractured Realities